The rule in one sentence
Section 104(a)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code excludes from income any damages received "on account of personal physical injuries or physical sickness", whether you receive them as a lump sum or in periodic payments. If you were hurt in a car accident, a fall or by a defective product, most or all of your settlement usually falls under that rule.
The details matter because a settlement is rarely one payment for one thing. The IRS looks at what each part of the money was paid for.
What is taxed and what isn't
| Part of the settlement | Taxable? | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Medical expenses | No | Unless you deducted those expenses in an earlier year |
| Lost wages in a physical injury claim | No | Treated as part of the physical injury damages |
| Pain and suffering from a physical injury | No | Includes emotional distress that flows from the injury |
| Emotional distress with no physical injury | Yes | Reduced by related medical costs you did not deduct |
| Punitive damages | Yes | Even when the underlying injury is physical |
| Interest on the settlement or judgment | Yes | Reported as interest income |
| Property damage (your car) | Usually no | Unless you receive more than the property's tax basis |
The IRS explains these categories in Publication 4345, which is short and worth reading if your settlement includes anything unusual.
Lost wages: why they are tax-free here but not always
People are often surprised that the wage part of an injury settlement is not taxed, since their paycheck would have been. The reason is that it is paid because of the physical injury, so it shares the injury's tax treatment.
The picture is different in an employment dispute. Back pay in a wrongful termination or discrimination case is taxable wages, usually with payroll taxes withheld. If your case mixes a workplace injury with an employment claim, how the settlement agreement divides the money matters a great deal.
Emotional distress: physical origin or not
Anxiety, sleep problems and depression after a crash that broke your wrist are treated as part of the physical injury. That money is tax-free.
Emotional distress on its own is different. Distress from defamation, harassment or a discrimination claim with no physical injury is taxable, although you can reduce the taxable amount by medical costs for treating that distress, such as therapy, that you have not already deducted.
Physical symptoms caused by emotional distress, such as headaches or stomach problems, generally do not turn distress damages into physical injury damages.
The trap: medical expenses you already deducted
If you itemized deductions in an earlier year and deducted medical bills from the accident, the part of your settlement that reimburses those bills becomes taxable, to the extent the deduction reduced your tax. The logic is simple: you should not get the tax benefit twice.
Example: you deducted $6,000 of accident-related medical expenses on last year's return and it lowered your tax. This year your settlement repays those bills. That $6,000 is reported as other income. The rest of your physical injury settlement stays tax-free.
Most people take the standard deduction, so this trap rarely applies, but check before you file.
Punitive damages and interest
Punitive damages are meant to punish the defendant, not to compensate you, so they are taxable even in a physical injury case. There is one narrow exception for certain wrongful death claims in a state whose law only allows punitive damages in those cases.
Interest is also taxable. That includes prejudgment interest a court adds and interest paid because a settlement was paid late. A defendant or insurer may send you a Form 1099-INT for it.
Attorney fees on a taxable settlement
If your whole settlement is tax-free, the lawyer's fee makes no tax difference. It matters when part of the money is taxable. Under the Supreme Court's decision in Commissioner v. Banks (2005), you are generally treated as receiving the full taxable amount, including the share paid to your lawyer. Since 2018 most individuals have not been able to deduct those fees, with exceptions for some employment and whistleblower claims. The result can be tax on money you never received.
This is one reason to think about taxes before a settlement is signed, not afterwards.
Why the wording of your settlement agreement matters
The IRS looks at why the payer made the payment. The best evidence is the settlement agreement. If the agreement says the money is paid for physical injuries, that supports tax-free treatment. If it is silent, or if it describes the payment as being for something else, you may have to explain it later.
Where a claim includes several parts, such as a physical injury and a punitive claim, ask for the agreement to allocate the money between them. The allocation has to be realistic. The IRS does not have to accept a split that does not reflect the claim.
Forms you might receive
Payers often do not issue a Form 1099 for damages paid for physical injury, because that money is not income. You might receive a 1099-MISC for taxable parts such as punitive damages, or a 1099-INT for interest. If you receive a form you think is wrong, contact the payer before you file, and keep the settlement agreement with your tax records.
Structured settlements
If you take a physical injury settlement as a series of payments over time instead of a lump sum, the payments are generally tax-free in full, including the part that reflects growth over time. That is different from investing a lump sum yourself, where the investment returns are taxable. Structured settlements have trade-offs, mainly less flexibility, so compare both options with a financial adviser.
State taxes and public benefits
Most states follow the federal treatment of injury settlements for income tax purposes, but check your own state.
Separately from tax, a settlement can affect means-tested benefits such as Medicaid or Supplemental Security Income. If you rely on those benefits, speak to a lawyer about options such as a special needs trust before the money arrives.
What to do before you sign
- Identify every part of the claim: physical injury, emotional distress, punitive, interest, property.
- Ask for a realistic allocation in the settlement agreement.
- Check whether you deducted any of the medical bills on an earlier return.
- If any part is taxable, estimate the tax and the effect of the attorney fee before you agree the figure.
- Keep the agreement, the settlement statement from your lawyer and any 1099 forms together.
For a sense of the overall size of your claim before you think about tax, use the settlement calculator.
Calculator
Estimate your settlement range
Full settlement range with your state's fault rule, fees and deadline.
This article is general information about US federal tax rules, not tax advice. Tax treatment depends on the facts of your claim, so check with a tax professional.